Explore the Zero Sum Game of FX Gains & Losses

Hedging foreign exchange risk can be viewed as a zero sum game, meaning that when one side of the hedge gains the other side loses. The degree by which those gains and losses do or do not perfectly offset depends on the derivative instrument, hedge coverage level, and strategy used. The FX hedge game isn't about winning or losing, it's about making the outcome more certain.

Balance sheet hedging is the most common practice among multinational corporations, and the goal is often to reduce foreign exchange gains and losses on the income statement to zero. The most effective way to largely achieve this goal is to hedge using a forward contract, which has a symmetrical payoff profile relative to the spot exchange rate, and to hedge 100% of the underlying exposure. However, even under this perfect scenario, there will still be residual FX gains and losses reported in earnings.

When companies hedge near 100% of their balance sheet exposures using forward contracts, controllers and treasurers often wonder why they are never able to achieve that zero sum outcome entirely. This is due to the forward point component of the forward rate on the derivative contract, and the fact that forward contracts are revalued based on forward rates compared to the underlying spot exposure, which is revalued based on spot exchange rates.

As a result, there will almost always be a difference in the "mark-to-market" accounting of a forward contract hedge and an underlying spot exposure. The only time this would not be the case is if interest rates were exactly equal for the countries or regions associated with the two currencies in the pair, which is highly uncommon. This is a typical area of frustration global corporations struggle with, and it highlights that understanding the accounting for underlying exposures and derivatives can clarify why there is a residual impact in earnings. Furthermore, it helps set realistic expectations as to what can be achieved when trying to play the zero sum game of FX hedging.

FX Initiative's Currency Risk Management Training covers balance sheet hedging in detail using Apple as an example to show how multinational corporations can hedge common exposures such as receivables and payables with forward contracts to mitigate foreign exchange gains and losses on the income statement. Our focus is on both the cash flow and financial reporting aspects of the hedge strategy, and we reinforce our teaching with visual displays of the economic and accounting ramifications.

If you are interested in learning how to hedge FX balance sheet exposures, forecasted transactions, and net investments in foreign subsidiaries, start your training today and explore our real world examples of all three scenarios. Furthermore, you can use our FX Transaction Simulator and Foreign Subsidiary Consolidator to customize your own risk model using company specific variables that reflect your actual exposures. Our video based curriculum puts academic theory into practice, and can help you and your team deliver more effective bottom line results in a time efficient manner. Take the FX Initiative for your organization by subscribing here.

Click here to subscribe >

Cheers,

The FX Initiative Team
support@fxinitiative.com

Learn Best Practice Accounting for FX Derivatives

Foreign exchange accounting is a complex area of financial reporting that many global organizations struggle with. Adding to that complexity, companies engaged in foreign exchange risk management must also learn how to account for currency derivatives. While the specific accounting rules differ between generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and international financial reporting standards (IFRS), the fundamental concepts are essential to understand when implementing foreign exchange risk management best practices for your international business.

Companies that hedge foreign exchange risk often have two main objectives: (1) To minimize the Income Statement impact of fluctuating foreign exchange rates, and (2) to reduce the variability in functional currency equivalent cash flows resulting from foreign currency transactions. In order to achieve the objective of minimizing the Income Statement impact of fluctuating foreign exchange rates, it is important to first consider the accounting treatment for the underlying position, and then to align the accounting treatment for the FX derivative accordingly.

At the highest level, companies can account for FX derivatives using “default” accounting treatment or “elective” accounting treatment. The “default accounting treatment requires that derivative gains and losses should be recorded in earnings on a current basis based on changes in their fair market value. The “elective” accounting treatment permits special accounting that results in changes in the fair value of the derivative to be recorded in the equity section of the balance sheet (rather than earnings) as part of other comprehensive income and then reclassified from the balance sheet to the income statement in the period or periods in which the underlying hedged item impacts consolidated earnings.

While the rules of elective accounting treatment can get quite complex, the key take away is that elective accounting treatment provides financial reporting benefits when hedging underlying exposures that do not impact the income statement on a current basis, such as forecasted transactions. Therefore, firms have a choice between the “default” and “elective” accounting treatment. FX Initiative’s currency risk management training addresses several variables to consider when choosing the most appropriate course of action for FX derivative accounting.

If you are interested in learning more about accounting for FX derivatives, FX Initiative’s currency risk management training walks you through real-world scenarios using Apple as an example. Specifically, we cover hedging forecasted revenue transactions, booked receivable transactions, and net investments in foreign subsidiaries using both elective and default accounting treatment. Learning how to account for FX derivatives is critical in order to achieve your foreign exchange risk management objectives. Start learning today by taking the FX Initiative!

Are you ready to learn best practice accounting for FX derivatives? Click here to take the FX Initiative!

Cheers,

The FX Initiative Team
support@fxinitiative.com